At ConnorCedro.com, every strategy I build is tested on my own websites first. That’s how I know my SEO delivers real results before I ever use it for a client.

In the digital age, your brand’s reputation isn’t what you say it is — it’s what others say about you online. Whether you’re a CEO looking at your personal brand or a company aiming to maintain customer trust, comprehensive online reputation management (ORM) is no longer optional. It’s a business imperative.

This blog covers what ORM is, why it matters, the key components of an effective ORM strategy, how to build and manage one, the challenges and pitfalls, and how to measure success. Let’s dive in.

At its core, online reputation management means monitoring, influencing and shaping how your business (or personal brand) is perceived on the internet. Semrush+2business.com+2

According to one definition:

Another adds that it comprises "all business activities that shape customers’ opinions of a company based on its online presence." business.com

In practice, this means you’re looking at what people see when they search for your brand, what they read in reviews, what they see on social media, what news outlets might say about you — and then actively working to steer that perception. InMoment

Important: ORM is not purely reactive. It’s not just about cleaning up a crisis. It’s also about proactively building a strong reputation, maintaining credibility, and safeguarding trust before something goes wrong. Sprout Social+1

Today’s buyers do their homework. They search your brand name and read reviews. If what they find is negative—or worse, nothing at all—they may steer away. For example, one source reports that around 59% of shoppers research online before buying, and 97% consult product reviews. Semrush+1

A poor or no visible reputation can therefore cost you not only traffic, but revenue.

When someone Googles your brand, what appears in the results forms their first impression. The top search results matter a lot. If negative or irrelevant content dominates page one, then you’re fighting an uphill battle. ORM often overlaps with SEO in that sense — by aiming to fill search-results with favourable or accurate content. reputationdefender.com+1

Negative reviews, social media backlash, or bad press can escalate fast. A strong reputation monitoring process helps you detect issues early, respond appropriately and avoid long-term damage. Sprout Social

It’s not just customers checking you out. Prospective employees, business partners, vendors, and investors also look at your online presence. A solid reputation opens doors. A weak one can close them.

Brands with stronger reputations win more often. They get more referrals, more trust, higher conversion rates — and often higher lifetime value from customers. Good ORM supports all of that.

Let’s break down the major elements every ORM strategy should include.

You can’t manage what you don’t measure. Monitoring means tracking mentions of your brand (and key people), reviews on third-party sites, social media chatter, search engine results, etc. Many tools exist to help with this. SendPulse+1

It also means understanding sentiment: are mentions positive, neutral, negative? What are the themes? Are there recurring issues?

Online reviews on platforms like Google, Yelp, Trustpilot, industry-specific review sites matter a lot. Responding to reviews — both positive and negative — builds trust and shows you care. For negative feedback, addressing it swiftly can turn a detractor into a promoter. Thryv Canada+1

Since many people will first encounter you via search, you want to ensure that high-quality, positive content dominates the first page. That could include optimised pages about your brand, positive press, blogs, case studies, etc. This is where SEO intersects with ORM. Search Engine Journal

Your own social channels (LinkedIn, Instagram, Twitter/X, Facebook, TikTok, etc) are part of your story. Using them to showcase brand values, customer success stories, leadership thought-pieces, helps build a positive narrative. Also monitor and respond to mentions here.

When something goes wrong—bad press, a product recall, a legal issue—you need plans in place. Rapid response, transparency, communication, and remediation can significantly mitigate long-term damage. This is why reputation is not just a marketing task but involves leadership, PR, and often legal input.

You don’t want to wait for crises. Proactively cultivate positive content, collect reviews, build partnerships, solicit user-generated content, share testimonials, engage influencers or advocates. This way you build a reputation cushion.

Track key metrics: number of brand mentions, sentiment analysis, volume of positive vs. negative reviews, average rating on review platforms, search-results share of positive content, etc. Reporting helps guide strategy and demonstrate ROI.

Here’s a step-by-step framework you can follow (or offer as a service) to build and scale an online reputation management program.

Start with a baseline. What does your search footprint look like? What reviews exist? What social mentions, blog posts, news articles? What sentiment do they reflect? Tools like Google Alerts, social listening platforms, review-monitoring dashboards help.

During the audit identify:

What are you trying to achieve? Possible goals: improve average rating from 3.5 to 4.5; increase % of page-one results that you control from 30% to 70%; reduce negative review backlog; increase mention volume of positive feedback; respond to reviews in <24 h.

Pick measurable metrics (KPIs) so you can track progress.

Set up systems and tools to monitor ongoing mentions, reviews, search results, and sentiment. Decide on responsibilities: who monitors, who responds, how escalation works.

Based on the audit, prioritise fixing high-impact issues. That might mean:

Create and distribute valuable content that supports your brand narrative: blog posts, customer testimonials, case studies, executive thought leadership, social posts. Engage with audiences and encourage user-generated content.

At the same time, build review-collection campaigns: ask satisfied customers to leave reviews, make it easy, follow up.

Be active on social channels: monitor mentions, respond to queries, join conversations where your brand is tagged or discussed. Use social listening to detect emerging issues early.

Have a plan in place for how you’ll respond to major reputation threats (negative viral posts, regulatory issues, product failures, lawsuits). Define roles and messaging templates ahead of time.

Use your KPIs to measure progress. Are average ratings improving? Is sentiment trending positive? Is negative content moving down in search results? Share reports with stakeholders. Use data to refine your strategy: double down on what works, pivot where needed.

Some negative content may be fake, motivated by competitors or trolls. While it’s difficult to remove every one, you can respond publicly with professionalism, flag inappropriate content on platforms, and encourage more genuine reviews to offset the risk.

You cannot control every mention or review. Some content may be inaccurate or defamatory. The goal isn’t perfect control — it’s strong influence, resilience, and timely response.

ORM is not “set and forget.” It demands ongoing effort from marketing, PR, customer service and sometimes legal. Build it into your process and budget accordingly.

Ranking and search-result behaviour is complex. Moving negative content off page one might require SEO skill, content creation, and link building. It’s a long-term play.

Some ORM tactics cross ethical lines (e.g., suppressing legitimate criticism, astroturfing reviews). Unscrupulous practices can backfire legally or reputationally. Be transparent and prioritize authenticity. Wikipedia

A small issue untreated can escalate into major brand damage. That’s why monitoring and early response are critical.

If you care about how your business is perceived online, take a few minutes to read Online Reputation Management: A Complete Guide. In this post, I explain how to build trust, handle negative reviews, and strengthen your brand image across all platforms. You’ll learn the strategies top companies use to protect their reputation, attract loyal customers, and grow with confidence in the digital world.

What does “success” look like? Here are metrics you can track:

By tracking these you can prove that ORM is impacting real outcomes (not just “we cleaned up search results”).

If you’re offering ORM as a service (for example you’re running a marketing agency, consultancy or SEO firm), here are some practical steps to build an effective offering:

Because reputation isn’t just a marketing problem — it touches multiple departments. Consider:

Thus, for ORM to succeed, you need to coordinate cross-functionally. Make reputation management part of your culture, not just a marketing add-on.

When you present ORM to stakeholders (executives, board, clients), use language that connects reputation to outcomes: leads, revenue, cost savings, risk mitigation. Some talking points:

Provide dashboards with simple metric trends and highlight the link between reputation and business metrics (e.g., higher retention, more referrals, lower acquisition cost).

Here’s a detailed multi-step framework to put ORM into action:

To manage ORM effectively you’ll need tools. Some features to look for: review monitoring, social listening, sentiment analysis, alerting, brand mention tracking, reporting dashboards. Qualtrics

Popular tool categories:

Choosing the right combination depends on your size, industry and risk level.

In the digital era, your reputation lives online — permanently. What someone finds when they search your brand can determine whether they become a customer, an employee, a partner, or an advocate.

Online reputation management isn’t a one-time fix. It’s a strategic, ongoing discipline that requires monitoring, building, responding and adapting. From reviews to search results to social sentiment, every touchpoint matters.

By investing in a robust ORM strategy, you’re not just protecting your brand — you’re enhancing trust, driving growth, reducing risk and building a resilient foundation for long-term success.

If you’d like support building an ORM audit, designing a content plan, or implementing review-growth processes, I can help you craft a tailored program (including templates, tools, and measurement frameworks) — just say the word.

Ready to grow your website traffic? Contact me to get your custom SEO strategy.

My 3-Step Process for SEO Success: